Introduction
If you’ve ever tried to track down a bottle of Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon, you know how elusive it can be. From limited allocations to skyrocketing secondary market prices, Blanton’s is a unicorn in today’s whiskey world. But here’s the good news—you don’t have to miss out on great bourbon just because Blanton’s isn’t on your shelf. There are plenty of alternatives that stand up to the hype and deliver equally satisfying pours.
In this article, we’ll break down the top 10 Blanton’s Single Barrel alternatives that are worth your time, money, and taste buds.
Why Blanton’s Single Barrel is So Popular
The Legacy of Blanton’s
Blanton’s, introduced in 1984 by Elmer T. Lee at Buffalo Trace, is considered the first commercially released single-barrel bourbon. This pioneering spirit set the stage for a new bourbon trend. Collectors love the horse stoppers, enthusiasts love the consistency, and casual drinkers love its smooth balance.
What Makes It Unique
Blanton’s has a rich caramel, vanilla, and citrus profile with a touch of spice, which makes it approachable yet complex. It’s also tied to Buffalo Trace’s limited production, which fuels its scarcity.
How to Choose a Good Alternative of Blanton’s Single Barrel
Flavor Profiles
When picking an alternative, think about whether you want the same caramel-forward sweetness, more spice, or extra oak influence.
Price Points and Availability
Unlike Blanton’s, which is hard to find without breaking the bank, these alternatives are often more affordable and widely available.
Collectability Factor
Some bourbons also come with collectible packaging or limited editions, making them appealing to both sippers and collectors.
Read Also: Indian whisky Indri creates history, becomes world’s No. 1 single malt
The Top 10 Blanton’s Single Barrel Alternatives
1. Buffalo Trace
Why It’s Comparable
Buffalo Trace is essentially Blanton’s younger sibling, coming from the same distillery. It’s smoother, slightly less complex, but carries similar DNA.
Taste and Price Overview
Expect notes of toffee, brown sugar, and vanilla at a fraction of Blanton’s cost—usually under $40.
2. Eagle Rare 10 Year
Key Flavor Notes
Eagle Rare brings oak, cocoa, and orange peel into the mix, giving it a richer, aged flavor.
Accessibility vs. Blanton’s
While it can be allocated, it’s still far easier to find than Blanton’s, usually around $45–$60.
3. Four Roses Single Barrel
Unique Characteristics
Known for its high-rye mash bill, this bourbon has bold spice with hints of honey and floral notes.
Value Proposition
At around $50, it delivers a complex sip that rivals Blanton’s without the frustration of hunting.
4. Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Classic Profile
Woodford Reserve offers a smooth and balanced flavor with dried fruit, caramel, and baking spice.
Why Enthusiasts Love It
It’s widely available and respected by bartenders, making it a reliable Blanton’s substitute.
5. Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Bold Flavor Notes
This barrel-proof bourbon is big, bold, and spicy—a different direction than Blanton’s but still a thrilling pour.
Price Advantage
Usually under $60, it offers more strength and intensity for your money.
6. Knob Creek 9 Year Single Barrel
Depth of Flavor
With deep oak, caramel, and vanilla, Knob Creek’s single barrel expression is a powerhouse.
Similarities to Blanton’s
Its sweetness and oakiness put it in the same league as Blanton’s, especially for those who enjoy a stronger kick.
7. Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style
Unique Edge
This bourbon has dark chocolate, espresso, and smoky richness, making it stand out while still appealing to Blanton’s fans.
Collectors’ Appeal
Part of the Whiskey Row series, it’s a bottle that both drinkers and collectors appreciate.
8. Maker’s Mark Cask Strength
Distinctive Taste
Maker’s Mark is wheated bourbon, so its softer, sweeter profile makes it different but still an excellent substitute.
Price and Strength Comparison
Around $50–$60, it’s widely available and packs a punch with higher proof.
9. Elijah Craig Barrel Proof
Flavor Explosion
Often called a bourbon lover’s dream, it boasts huge flavors of caramel, cinnamon, and oak.
How It Stacks Up Against Blanton’s
It’s hotter and bolder, but if you love depth, it’s a fantastic alternative.
10. Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel
Traditional Yet Distinct
Russell’s Reserve brings vanilla, toffee, and spice with a long, lingering finish.
Market Position
At around $60, it’s a premium choice that often outshines Blanton’s in blind tastings.
Expert Tips for Enjoying Alternatives
Best Ways to Drink
While purists will say neat, you can also enjoy these bourbons on the rocks, in an Old Fashioned, or even in a bourbon-forward Manhattan.
Pairing Ideas
Try pairing bourbon with dark chocolate, smoked meats, or aged cheeses for an elevated experience.
Read Also: Tasting the Perfect Fifth Canongate 15-Year-Old American Whiskey
Conclusion
Blanton’s Single Barrel may have a cult following, but it’s not the only bourbon worth sipping. From Buffalo Trace’s affordable charm to Elijah Craig Barrel Proof’s explosive depth, these 10 alternatives prove that the bourbon world is full of hidden gems. So next time you can’t find Blanton’s, don’t sweat it—grab one of these bottles and raise a glass.
FAQs
Q1: Why is Blanton’s so hard to find?
Blanton’s is produced in limited quantities at Buffalo Trace, and demand far exceeds supply.
Q2: Are these alternatives cheaper than Blanton’s?
Yes, most of these options are half the price of Blanton’s, making them excellent value picks.
Q3: Which alternative is closest in flavor to Blanton’s?
Buffalo Trace and Eagle Rare share the closest DNA due to being from the same distillery.
Q4: Can I still collect alternatives like Blanton’s?
Yes, bottles like Four Roses Single Barrel and Old Forester 1920 have collectible appeal.
Q5: What’s the best alternative for cocktails?
Woodford Reserve and Maker’s Mark Cask Strength are bartender favorites for cocktails.
1 thought on “Top 10 Blanton’s Single Barrel Alternatives That Actually Compare”